The Toronto Blue Jays should have fired J.P. Ricciardi, but instead, the people who run Ted Rogers’ baseball team, decided on Friday that manager John Gibbons should go.
The Jays, wallowing in last place in the American League East, were 35-39 and had lost five straight when Gibbons was gassed and replaced by Cito Gaston, the special assistant to Jays president, Paul Godfrey.
When Gibbons was fired, the Jays had lost 13 of 17 and fallen 10 1/2 games behind first-place Boston in the AL East. On Friday night, when Toronto played Pittsburgh — and Gaston was the manager — the Jays lineup went like this…
1. Marco Scutaro, 2B
2. Lyle Overbay 1B
3. Alex Rios RF
4. Vernon Wells, CF
5. Scott Rolen, 3B
6. Rod Barajas, C
7. Kevin Mench, LF
8. John McDonald, SS
9. Roy Halladay, P
Frankly, that’s an awful lineup. Barely big league. Late in the game, the Jays used Brad Wilkerson, Matt Stairs and Joe Inglett as pinch hitters. Still, it didn’t matter. The final score: Pittsburgh 1, Toronto 0 in 12 innings. The Jays fell to 35-40 and they’d now lost six straight.
Well, why wouldn’t they lose? Why should they win, even with Doc Halladay on the mound? Marco Scutaro is a .248 hitter with nine extra base hits in 202 at bats; Lyle Overbay is a .262 hitter with six homers; Alex Rios is hitting .272 with only three homers and 27 RBI in 290 at bats hitting out of the No. 3 hole; Vernon Wells has struggled through injuries and is hitting .277 in only 148 at bats; Scott Rolen has battled through injuries and is hitting only .268 with three homers; at .289 in 142 at bats, Rod Barajas is the best hitter on the team (Rod Barajas???); Kevin Mench, who had been released by Milwaukee, is hitting .217 (no surprise there); John McDonald is hitting .171; Brad Wilkerson, released earlier this year by last-place Seattle is hitting .244; Joe Inglett is hitting .291 with only one home run in 86 at bats; and Matt Stairs is hitting .255, but at least he has eight homers.
The Jays are hitting .257 as a team, baseball’s 21st best overall. In terms of the major league standings, they are 19th overall. That’s the Blue Jays. People who believe the Jays have a good team are delusional. The pitching is decent, but the team has no power and doesn’t hit for average. Only the Minnesota Twins (46) and Los Angeles Dodgers (48) have hit fewer homers than Toronto (49). It doesn’t run badly (47 steals), but has been caught stealing 23 times, third most in the game. And they field the ball pretty well, fifth in the American League.
But they can’t hit. They can’t score. And if you can’t score in the Majors today, you can’t win.
J.P. Ricciardi handed John Gibbons a bad team. Cito Gaston won’t be able to fix it. Unless the Jays find themselves a general manager who can legitimately build a team (Pat Gillick, perhaps?), then the franchise will never again find success.