
Rick Nash Stays in Columbus
WINNIPEG – The Trade Deadline has passed. Now it’s time to pay one final visit to our 30 National Hockey League franchises.
We got most of the deals right, or at least, close to right, although we did not believe the New Jersey Devils would be involved as much as they were, we firmly believed the Columbus Blue Jackets would try to move Rick Nash and we figured the Toronto Maple Leafs would do a lot more to try and acquire the players necessary to get themselves into the playoffs.
None of that happened and that’s why I must admit I felt sympathy for the poor hair-spray heads that spent the day on television trying to make something out of nothing.
And Trade Deadline Day was indeed, about absolutely nothing. In total, there were 15 trades involving 30 players and 11 draft picks but only a handful might be termed “major” (and I use that term lightly) trades:
1. The Vancouver Canucks sent a couple of 2012 draft picks to the Columbus Blue Jackets in exchange for forward Sami Pahlsson.

Andrei Kostitsyn off to Nashville
2. The Montreal Canadiens sent forward Andrei Kostitsyn to Nashville in exchange for a couple of draft picks in 2013.
3. The Edmonton Oilers sent defenseman Tom Gilbert to Minnesota in exchange for defenseman Nick Schultz.
5. The Boston Bruins acquired forward Brian Rolston and defenseman Mike Mottau from the New York Islanders in exchange for a couple of prospects.
6. The Nashville Predators acquired Paul Gaustad and a fourth-round draft pick from the Buffalo Sabres in exchange for a first round pock in 2012.
Making an eight-hour TV show out of that has to be painful.
Here’s one final look at the winners and losers on Trade Deadline Day in the NHL:
Anaheim Ducks: GM Bob Murray said he would trade his top players, but as his team played better (they just went 5-1-2 on an eight-game road trip and are 7-1-2 in their last 10 to get back in the playoff hunt), it appeared as if his threats were made to scare the beejeezus out of a group of guys who saw themselves in Winnipeg or Edmonton and didn’t like the thought. The Ducks did nothing of significance and as a result, they were WINNERS.

Brian Rolston clears waivers and is then dealt to the Bruins
Boston Bruins: Despite the fact Peter Chiarelli didn’t believe there would be much available, he did a marvelous job. He acquired veteran defensemen Mike Mottau (New Jersey) and Greg Zanon (Minnesota) and veteran forward Brian Rolston (New Jersey) and added grit, playmaking ability and experience to an already solid lineup. The Bruins were already a good hockey team. With what they did on deadline day, they were definitely WINNERS.
Buffalo Sabres: The disappointing Sabres dumped Paul Gaustad and got a first round pick from Nashville in 2012. They also picked up forward Cody Hodgson and defenseman Alexander Sulzer from Vancouver in exchange for forward Zack Kassian and defenseman Marc-Andre Gragnani. Hodgson and Sulzer will make the Sabres better moving forward. In all, the Sabres were WINNERS.
Calgary Flames: As expected, the Flames did nothing. They believe they have the people who can get them into the playoffs and there was no reason to give up too much. A WASH.
Carolina Hurricanes: Hurricanes GM Jim Rutherford wanted to do something but couldn’t pull the trigger. The Canes still have too many veterans with the wrong attitude. LOSERS.

Hawks get Johnny Oduya from the Jets
Chicago Blackhawks: The Hawks went after a defenseman and got exactly what they wanted. Former Blackhawks assistant GM Kevin Cheveldayoff sent his former boss, Stan Bowman, Johnny Oduya for a second-round and third-round pick in 2013. The Blackhawks got what they were after – a fast defenseman with the ability to move the puck. WINNERS.
Colorado Avalanche: The Avalanche acquired Steve Downie from Tampa in exchange for Kyle Quincey, but they are pleased with their maturing team and figure they still have a shot at the post-season. A WASH.
Columbus Blue Jackets: The worst team in the NHL traded away Jeff Carter and Antoine Vermette, but it didn’t trade away Rick Nash. The question is, did they do enough to get significantly better? And make no mistake, this team had to get significantly better. Well, there is no question defenseman Jack Johnson will help them, a first round pick in 2013 will eventually help them, two middle of the pack draft picks in 2012 won’t hurt them. A WASH today, but could be a WINNER after 2013.

Nicklas Grossman sent to Flyers
Dallas Stars: The Stars sent Nicklas Grossman to Philly this past week for a second-round pick in 2012 and a third-round pick in 2013 and acquired journeyman Eric Nystrom from Minnesota for futures. WINNERS.
Detroit Red Wings: GM Ken Holland acquired Kyle Quincey for a first round draft pick (probably 29th or 30th overall). Quincey scored in his first game with Detroit. Holland also dumped defenseman Mike Commodore for a seventh-round pick. A WASH.
Edmonton Oilers: The Oilers dealt Tom Gilbert, who they weren’t happy with, to get Nick Schultz and they’re happy with the deal. A WASH.
Florida Panthers: The Panthers acquired Wojtek Wolski from the Rangers on Saturday for defenseman Mike Vernace and a third-round pick in 2013 and Jerred Smithson from the Predators on Friday for a draft pick. WINNERS.
Los Angeles Kings: The Kings couldn’t get rid of LW Dustin Penner, but they didn’t expect anyone would want him. The Kings did get Jeff Carter, but gave up D Jack Johnson and a first-round pick to get him. LOSERS.

Wild get Tom Gilbert
Minnesota Wild: The Wild got rid of F Eric Nystrom, D Marek Zidlicky, D Greg Zanon and D Nick Schultz, but acquired D Tom Gilbert, D Steve Kampfer, D Kurtis Foster, F Nick Palmieri, F Stephane Veilleux, a second-round pick in 2012 and a third-round pick in 2013. They didn’t get worse and might have improved. WINNERS
Montreal Canadiens: The Habs traded away Hal Gill, Andrei Kostitsyn and a fifth-round pick and got a second-round pick in 2013, a fifth-round pick in 2013, a second-round pick in 2012, Blake Geoffrion, Robert Slaney. The struggling Canadiens needed to do a lot more than they did at the deadline and have obviously written off 2011-12. Fact is, they didn’t get better. They couldn’t get worse. LOSERS.
Nashville Predators: The Predators acquired Hall Gill and Andrei Kostitsyn and they are a better team heading down the stretch. GM David Poile was happy to wait until the draft to either make a deal with all-star defenseman and soon-to-be unrestricted free agent Ryan Suter, or trade him. WINNERS.

The Devils get Marek Zidlicky
New Jersey Devils: GM Lou Lamoriello did a lot more than we expected and it all helped make his team better and younger. He acquired Marek Zidlicky from Minnesota and sent Kurtis Foster, Nick Palmieri, Stephane Veilleux and two draft picks to get Zidlicky from Minnesota. The Devils got better. WINNERS.
New York Islanders: The Islanders needed to get better and they did nothing to improve. However, they did send Rolston and Mottau to Boston for prospects so they might get better in 2014. A WASH.
New York Rangers: GM Glen Sather didn’t do much, but he did get big D John Scott from Chicago for a draft pick so he didn’t hurt himself. When you’re in first place and playing well, there is no sense doing anything stupid. WINNERS.
Ottawa Senators: Sens GM Bryan Murray has said he doubted he’d do anything at the deadline and that was smart. Why significantly change a team that has responded well to rookie head coach Paul MacLean? He did pick up prospect goalie Ben Bishop for a second round pick in 2013 and that can’t hurt. WINNERS.

The Flyers acquired Pavel Kubina
Philadelphia Flyers: The Flyers didn’t add any depth up front, but they did acquire defensemen Pavel Kubina and Nicklas Grossman this past week in hopes they can replace the injured Chris Pronger. Both were good moves. WINNERS.
Phoenix Coyotes: The league figures this team can make the playoffs with what it already possesses. Just like Calgary, Phoenix’s trade deadline day was A WASH.
Pittsburgh Penguins: The Penguins are a very good team that knows it can’t replace Sidney Crosby. Even if Crosby doesn’t come back, it was always unlikely the Pens would be involved in anything significant on Deadline Day. The fact they did nothing stupid makes them WINNERS.
San Jose Sharks: The Sharks got Dominic Moore from Tampa so they got the “third-line energy guy” they were after. They picked up F Daniel Winnik and F T.J., Gagliardi and a seventh-round pick from Colorado for three prospects. WINNERS.
St. Louis Blues: The Blues liked their team and got a second-round pick for prospect goalie Ben Bishop. A WASH.
Tampa Bay Lightning: The Lightning were prepared to deal. They sent Dominic Moore to San Jose, Steve Downie to Colorado and Pavel Kubina to Philly. They also picked up three prospects and a first-round pick in 2012 (probably 29th or 30th from Detroit). A WASH for now, but maybe WINNERS after the season.
Toronto Maple Leafs: The Leafs did nothing of significance to a team that needed help. They messed around with a couple of prospects. They did not get better, probably because they had nothing to trade. They are 2-7-1 in their last 10, have fallen out of the playoffs and are heading toward the bottom of the Eastern Conference. LOSERS.

Former Manitoba Moose Cody Hodgson is out of Vancouver and off to Buffalo
Vancouver Canucks: The Canucks acquired D Sami Pahlsson and D Marc-Andre Gragnani and a couple of prospects. They gave up Cody Hodgson, a couple of prospects and a middle of the pack draft pick. WINNERS.
Washington Capitals: The Caps did nothing to get better and they needed to get better. LOSERS.
Winnipeg Jets: The Jets are in the playoff hunt and they like their mix. However, they traded over-priced and soon-to-be-unrestricted-free-agent D Johnny Oduya for a second and third-round draft pick in 2013 and did nothing to upset the chemistry that has them fighting for first in the Southeast Division. WINNERS.